Should Hospitals be Run by Doctors? Exploring the Pros and Cons

Should hospitals be run by doctors?
Among the nearly 6,500 hospitals in the United States, only 235 are run by physician administrators, according to a 2009 study in the journal Academic Medicine. But now new research suggests that having a doctor in charge at the top is connected to overall better patient care and a better hospital.

Hospitals are a vital component of any healthcare system because they offer patients the necessary medical attention and care. However, there has long been discussion about who should be in charge of these institutions. While some contend that doctors should manage hospitals, others feel that non-medical workers are more qualified for the job. In this piece, we’ll examine both strategies’ benefits and drawbacks.

The argument in favor of doctors managing hospitals is predicated on the notion that they possess the essential medical knowledge to make defensible choices regarding patient care and treatment. Doctors are more qualified to handle these problems successfully because they are more familiar with the specific difficulties and intricacies of the healthcare system. Additionally, doctors are more inclined to put patients before money, ensuring that hospitals deliver high-quality care that is tailored to each patient’s needs.

However, having doctors run hospitals has certain disadvantages as well. For starters, doctors can lack the managerial abilities required to oversee the financial and organizational facets of managing a hospital. Additionally, doctors could lack management and leadership training, which can affect employee morale and productivity. The sole proprietorship is an additional type of medical business that closes with the death of the owner. When a single person who owns and runs this kind of practice passes away, the business usually comes to an end. Patients who depend on the services offered by these practices may be left without access to care, which might be troublesome.

Due to the increased demand for care and the requirement for additional resources like PPE and ventilators during the COVID-19 pandemic, hospitals have experienced severe financial difficulties. As a result of having to postpone elective surgeries and other treatments in order to make room for COVID patients, several hospitals have experienced financial losses during this period. However, by changing their business practices and locating new revenue streams, several hospitals have been able to maintain their profitability.

The cost of masks has been one of the biggest outlays made by hospitals during the COVID-19 pandemic. The American Hospital Association reported that hospitals pay, on average, $0.04 each mask. Even though this might seem like a little sum, it soon mounts up when hospitals use hundreds or thousands of masks per day.

To sum up, the subject of whether hospitals should be managed by physicians lacks a simple solution. Despite their significant medical competence, doctors might lack the managerial and leadership qualities needed to efficiently manage hospitals. In the end, the greatest strategy might be to administer hospitals and give patients high-quality treatment as a team of specialists with a variety of talents.

FAQ
What are the 4 types of hospitals?

General hospitals, specialty hospitals, teaching hospitals, and government hospitals make up the four different categories of hospitals. While speciality hospitals concentrate on certain medical diseases or treatments, general hospitals offer a wide range of healthcare services. Teaching hospitals, which are connected to medical schools, offer future healthcare professionals instruction. Public healthcare is offered by government-run hospitals, which are operated by the government.

Who owns most hospitals in America?

The majority of hospitals in America are not owned by certain physicians. Instead, they are owned by a variety of groups, including businesses, nonprofits, and governmental bodies.

Leave a Comment